'Big Picture' Regional Thoughts

Moral Cover vs Moral License

When enforcement becomes selective, deterrence turns into permission.

The cost of impunity

The U.S. policing its backyard with such brazen impunity has done more than destabilise Latin America. It has whitewashed Putin’s actions in Ukraine and quietly removed any remaining hesitation Xi Jinping may have harboured over Taiwan.

At a broader level, global governance based on “do as I say, not as I do” has a very short geopolitical shelf life. Moral authority, once compromised, doesn’t degrade slowly — it collapses.

Timing, symbolism, and Chinese calculus

If aggression toward Taiwan were to materialise, the timing matters. The period after Chinese New Year (17–18 February) aligns more comfortably with Chinese astrological thinking. Historically, the Year of the Fire Horse has been associated with internal upheaval, rebellion, or the collapse of an established order.

Whether one subscribes to astrology or not, symbolism plays a real role in decision-making at the highest levels — particularly in systems where long memory and historical pattern are taken seriously.

Oil’s diminished shock value

Oil markets, scarred by years of disruption, sanctions, and conflict, may barely flinch. The South China Sea has been priced for tension for a long time. Supply chains are bruised, diversified, and largely desensitised.

In that sense, oil is no longer the tripwire it once was.

The real fault line: chips

The true vulnerability lies elsewhere — semiconductors. TSMC controls roughly 70% of global contract chip manufacturing. Samsung, the nearest competitor, holds just 7–8%. There is no redundancy. No meaningful substitute.

A disruption there hits everyone — including China. That self-inflicted cost is likely what lends weight to the darker interpretation of the Fire Horse omen.

America’s exposed flank

For the U.S., the consequences would be immediate. The S&P 500 is propped up by the Magnificent Seven — all of whom are structurally dependent on Taiwanese manufacturing. A shock to TSMC isn’t a supply-chain issue; it’s a market event.

The bigger picture

This isn’t about right or wrong. It’s about moral cover becoming moral license. When enforcement looks selective, restraint evaporates. Precedent replaces principle.

Oil may shrug.
Markets may not.

And the world may soon discover that credibility, once spent, can’t be hedged back.

Explore our Data. Discover the Alpha.

Receive two weeks of our Maven Knowledge reporting. No cost, no obligation.