'Big Picture' Regional Thoughts

VLSFO / Hi-5: The 0.5% Cash Book Squeeze

How China’s growing appetite for low-sulphur feedstock threatens the marine bunker pool and could create a new Hi-5 super-spike.

Paper desks looking purely at standard Singapore 0.5% and 380cst curves are missing the structural reality beneath the surface.

In the physical market, we are starting to witness the permanent cannibalisation of the global low-sulphur cash book.

Compliant barrels are now being swallowed whole by China as feedstock, permanently removed from even their own bonded marine bunker pool.

3.5% had China covered comfortably when Hormuz was open, and it left the 380cst derivatives curve alone because it never had a presence there in the first place.

But for China to reposition that entire appetite towards organically made, legitimate 0.5% is unfathomable, given the scarcity by comparison.

These are the ones to take note of from our North Asia arrivals:

Mid China (State Oil Company)
Status / ETAVesselVolume (kt)ProductLoad DatesOriginTermsCounterparty
ETA 28 OctBARBAROSA149LSSR27–29 AugDangoteRNRAramco
ETA 28 OctEMERALD SPIRIT104LSFO7–9 SepBrazilRNRPetrobras
ETA 13 NovMATALA139LSFO20–22 SepRotterdamRNRUnknown

These are all first-time movements to be waved straight through, bypassing the MOC entirely.

North China (Teapots)
Status / ETAVesselVolume (kt)ProductLoad DatesOriginTermsCounterpartyDestination
DischargedKASTOS52HSFO16 AugSt. PetersburgRNRPetrorussLongkou
DischargedKASTOS52HSFO20 AugUst LugaRNRPetrorussLongkou
DischargedEL BELLA20HSFO11–13 SepKarachiO/PTrafiguraLaizhou
DischargedEL BELLA20HSFO16–18 SepKarachiO/PTrafiguraLaizhou
AnchoredSOFIA II100HSFO18–19 AugUst LugaRNR2RiversLongkou
ETA 31 OctFRONT SHANGHAI145HSWEET24–26 AugScapa FlowRNRBPQingdao
ETA 3 NovLIMBO82HSFO19–21 AugUst LugaRNR2RiversDalian
ETA 20 NovTRIDENT 9140HSFO1–3 OctUst LugaRNRPetrorussYantai

They have to play second fiddle to their oil companies, so they are taking mid-range HSFOs as their feedstocks (Karachi 2.3%, St. Petersburg 2.6%).

But you can see why they are concurrently refining a Kraken Heavy Sweet, which is 70% 0.5%.

And the agenda with that won’t be supporting the Chinese bunkering community; it will be to use the subsequent yield as a low-sulphur feedstock.

Their advantage over their oil company contemporaries, however, is that they can access the low-sulphur VGO from Eastern Russia, which the oil companies can’t touch.

The Elevator: The Death of Cutter and the Extinction of the Marginal Barrel

Component pricing and inventory have always been the most difficult pieces of the puzzle to ascertain unless you’re sitting at one of the Big 5 Trading Houses.

And I think even they would admit they have to put a lot of focus into drawing a lucid conclusion on that on any given day.

Competing on this front as an issue now seems to have been permanently kicked into the long grass.

All those 1.5%–1.6% barrels now (from India and the like) will get sucked into the Chinese feedstock vortex. If the state oil companies don’t want them, the teapots will.

The Trajectory: From IMO 2020 Compliance to 2026 Feedstock Starvation

To understand where pricing is heading, we must look at how the 0.5% market structure has evolved over the past decade:

  • 2017 — The Synthetic Era: Trading desks improvised, using Gasoil vs. 380cst HSFO paper as crude and crack proxies to manufacture synthetic Hi-5 exposure before physical structures existed.
  • 2019 — The Cleared Baseline: On January 31, the first formal Hi-5 trade cleared, establishing the foundational 0.5% vs. 380cst swap curve just months ahead of the global mandate.
  • 2020 — The Regulatory Super-Spike: On January 1, the IMO 0.5% global sulphur cap detonated, driving the Hi-5 spread to its historic physical peak as refiners scrambled for every available cutter stock to meet spec compliance.
  • 2026 — The Feedstock Black Hole & Blind Netting: The shock is no longer about regulatory specification compliance. The bottleneck is now upstream structural starvation.
Strategic Outlook

We’re probably looking at a variation of the Hi-5 super-spike of 2020. The delta should blow out massively.

As for a contango play on the physical, you’ve got a judgement call to make on purchase vs. lease:

VesselCapacityPurchaseLease
Old Aframax700 kb$52 million$225,000/day
Old Suezmax1.0 mb$61 million$400,000/day